Government tasks (sarkaar): The tasks that government carries out using tax money.
Voluntary collective (samaaj): People supporting a cause who come together, pool money and work for the cause. Unlike the taxes collected by government under threat of a gun, the contribution to the collective is entirely voluntary. Example: Ramkrishna Mission, Resident Welfare Associations, etc.
Market (bazaar): Profits in free markets drive this entity. No coercion, only earning through customer satisfaction.
I prefer to restrict the government to only those tasks which need some form of coercion or force. Like police, military, judiciary, community discipline in case of pandemic etc.
I want to explain the above with some examples:
Task | Responsibility |
---|---|
Impoverished seniors | Voluntary collective |
Military spending | Government |
Community health, pandemic | Government |
Education for poor | Voluntary collective |
Helthcare for poor | Voluntary collective |
Homelessness | Voluntary collective |
UBI | Voluntary collective |
Bail out industry | Market. Industry should create its own rainy day buffer out of its profit/initial investment. If no longer feasible to run the industry, shut it down. |
Regulatory Agencies. RBI, IRDA, CSRIL, RERA | Government. It is government's job to prevent chaos across industries such as Finance, Insurance Real estate. Thanks to Ashutosh for this point. |
Non intrusive testing/tracing capabilities for pandemic management | Government. This is public-health-issue, as opposed to personal healthcare. But I cannot imagine any government building a tracking/tracing capability which it won't misuse by invading into citizen privacy. Honouring privacy requires ethics of the highest order, and no government can maintain high ethics. |
None of the ideas is my original. It is a synthesis of ideas that I picked up over the years from Swaminomics, Atanu Dey, Gurucharan Das, Paul Graham, Ayn Rand, Amlan Dutta, Ashok Desai.
No comments:
Post a Comment